Book Crits

5 Reasons Why I hated Norwegian Wood by Haruki Murakami

The second book I picked up this year is Norwegian Wood by Haruki Murakami. I’ve heard from many people how great of an author he is and how wonderful this book is and so, I decided to give it a try. But it left me greatly disappointed!

I wanted to quit this book several times while reading it but then tried to finish it forcibly because I wanted to finish my Goodreads reading challenge this year. Anyway, here’s the review of possibly my worst read of the year.

A fun fact:

Norwegian Wood by Haruki Murakami is claimed to be the book read by everyone in Japan. Its international popularity compelled Murakami to even flee the country and escape media attention.

Haruki Murakami is a Japanese author and it is a 1987 novel. His other works include The wind-up bird Chronicle, A wild sheep chase, 1Q84, Kafka on the Shore, Hear the wind sing, etc.

Book Blurb:

Toru, a quiet and preternaturally serious young college student in Tokyo, is devoted to Naoko, a beautiful and introspective young woman, but their mutual passion is marked by the tragic death of their best friend, Kizuki, years before.

Toru begins to adapt to campus life and the loneliness and isolation he faces there, but Naoko finds the pressures and responsibilities of life unbearable. As she retreats further into her own world, Toru finds himself reaching out to others and drawn to a fiercely independent young woman.

norwegian wood by haruki murakami

Norwegian Wood Book Review:

Giving a one-word review about this book is a tad tough. I had different opinions on this book at different points while reading it. But the final conclusion is something I did not expect.

Let’s go point by point.

5 Reasons Why I Hated Norwegian Wood by Haruki Murakami

One,

It’s a 1987 novel but it’s so free-spirited… in a bad way. At least for me, it somehow did not sit well with me to think people were so back in the day. I mean, if it’s from this time, I definitely wouldn’t be this shocked.

Two,

I started reading it and believe me, the first few pages were amazing. The way he narrated the time spent in the meadow with the girl he likes made me feel like I’m about to read a great love story. I felt this book is something I could definitely read for a second time, or maybe even a third.

This was my initial impression, of course.

norwegian wood by haruki murakami

But when I got into the story a little bit, I felt maybe I should have picked another book because the story was not that good but the writing style of Murakami is pretty impressive. Especially, when he describes the quiet and calm life of people in the mountains, the red birds against the blue sky and the nature they were surrounded by is so very amazing.

Three,

If we see the story in general, it was, um, bad. I can’t find any other word. I disliked it. You know, how at the end of the book we fall in love with a character or two from the story? We know they are fictional but still, we admire them. For this book, believe me when I say I have not found such a character in all 386 pages. Not one. But ask me if I hated any character,  yes!!! I hated most of them, especially the protagonist. But then again, I told myself ‘It’s just a story.

And the protagonist, Toru Watanabe, is such a bad egg. Yet he considers himself an honest person. I don’t know if I hate or pity this character. The story keeps progressing and I was almost in the middle of the book, but I had not quite caught what the protagonist wants to achieve. Like, the whole purpose of the story. Just looking back at his past, that’s all.

There were three female leads in the story, Naoko, Midori, and Reiko, but all three of them are just sad. All three of them keep blabbering away about their issues, troubles, and opinions and I could say that the writer got carried away and it became a little too much.

Four,

The central theme of the story was deaths, suicides, and mental illnesses. The writer might have the right intentions about bringing awareness or something about such stuff but even that didn’t work out. Overall, it didn’t give me a good vibe.

Five,

At the end of every book, I wait to feel good. One because I have finished one more book and two because I like happy endings. And Norwegian wood did not give me any of those vibes. It comes off as dark and disturbing. And as it’s said in the blurb I did not seem to feel such devoted love for Naoko from Toru and it’s definitely far from heroic. It baffles me to see such hype for this book.

Would I recommend this book to anyone?

No.

Rating:

1.5/5

Even that 1.5 is for the beautiful sceneries of mountain life Murakami described in the book. Then again, Jay Rubin should be partly given credit for the translation. Also, there were a few interesting perspectives on life.

Like this one;

“If you only read the books that everyone else is reading, you can only think what everyone else is thinking.”

That’s nice, but just for that, I would never pick a book of 386 pages of utter nonsense. I’d use Google!!

So, have you read this by any chance? What’s your opinion?

If you liked it, then it’s fine. Opinions differ, but let me know why you liked it. I’d love to know. And before Norwegian Wood, I read Tell me three things by Julie Buxbaum. If interested, read its review as well.

My next read is going to be Frankenstein and let’s see how it would go!

Lots of LOVE,

Nikki.

(Penname: Sarvani)



 

Summary
Review Date
Reviewed Item
Norwegian Wood
Author Rating
21star1stargraygraygray
Product Name
Norwegian Woord

6 thoughts on “5 Reasons Why I hated Norwegian Wood by Haruki Murakami

  1. Honestly I think you missed the point of the book. Yes it is about depression, suicide and mental health but I believe it is wrong to say that a person with mental health would feel worse by reading the book. A a matter of fact, Murakami is bringing to light the unfortunate reality of these issues, unlike the fantasized version of depression which many have adopted these days. Furthermore, the fact that the ending is so ambiguous is unique and opens the door to many different interpretations. This point is furthered by the fact that every character is flawed, which many authors are afraid to do as it allows room for criticism but also reflects just what every human being is – flawed. Not just the female characters, but every single character has a captivating backstory and draws the reader into the world of 1960s Japan. However, I understand if ‘Norwegian Wood’ is not to your liking, it is arguably a controversial book and I have met many who do not like it just like you. To each their own.

    1. Yes, I see your point. But I give more weight to how I feel while reading a book, just my personal taste. Although I honestly feel it’s not worth the hype. There’s a lot of inconsistency in characters, especially the MC.

      I’m glad you shared your opinion as it broadens my perspective. Thanks 🙂

      But I guess you’re right. Maybe I was a bit harsh. So editing it out.

Leave a Reply to Best Of February 2020 | Bedu: Bedouin Boy, Poet King - Nikki's talk Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *